Book Report: Adventures of a Female Medical Detective

The Adventures of a Female Medical Detective, by Mary Guinan, is a wonderful, complimentary read to House On Fire (which I also wrote a review about).

Early in her career, Dr. Mary Guinan worked as a doctor and epidemiologist for the World Health Organization during the small pox eradication efforts in India and Pakistan. Her efforts involved interviewing patients and contacts of patients, pleading with local leaders to allow work to happen in their communities, and tracking down every case of small pox in the most remote corners of India. She tells a charming story about trying to get her budget for her elephant-feed approved. Indeed, a wealthy Indian man turned up with an elephant and an elephant-driver to expedite her work as he (the elephant, not the man) could easily cross rivers and slug all of their equipment.

Her career progressed and over time she cared for patients living with HIV, worked in a Pakistani refugee camp, and became the go-to for all questions and concerns related to herpes. My favorite antidote from the book is when  “Dr. Condom”, as she was known, was asked in 1978 about the risk of getting HIV from a toilet seat, she responded: “The only way I know of that you can get AIDS from a toilet seat is if you sit down on it before someone else gets up.” She was on fire.

I enjoyed this book, I did. I wish that there were more details in it and that it was written with an assumption that the reader would like to hear more about decision-making processes and, frankly, details of her life. She is a remarkable person by all accounts—becoming a doctor when only 10% in the field were women, winning the jackpot to become one of the 45 to land a spot in the CDCs Epidemic Intelligence Service , rejection after rejection for her applications to study chemistry because she’s a woman– and yet, when it comes to her life and her ability to overcome adversity, the book fell flat. Many of the chapters left me wanting more, to learn more, or to even be able to relate to her more and see her as an example.

Is it worth a read? Yes, especially since it is short, funny, and entertaining. Well, at least as entertaining as a book about an epidemiologist can be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept that my given data and my IP address is sent to a server in the USA only for the purpose of spam prevention through the Akismet program.More information on Akismet and GDPR.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.